Newcastle United looked close to sealing a deal to bring James Trafford to St James Park this summer, but he chose a move to Manchester City instead.
Newcastle then signed Aaron Ramsdale on loan to compete with the declining Nick Pope for the starting berth.
Advertisement
Unfortunately, it has been a lose-lose situation for all parties involved. The Geordies did not get their man. He is not getting game time.
Meanwhile, Ramsdale’s time at Newcastle has been uninspiring. Since usurping Pope’s place, he has not done enough to encourage the club to buy him permanently.
His Premier League goals prevented stat is an appalling -2.39. after seven appearances.
He has yet to keep a clean sheet. He is not the authoritative presence the Toons need between the sticks.
For comparison sake, Trafford has kept a clean sheet and recorded goals prevented of 1.89 in three appearances.
Advertisement
The 23-year-old recently impressed in the FA Cup against Salford, keeping another clean sheet, before expressing his frustration at being the second-choice goalie.
He thought he’d be the first choice going into the season, but City signed Gianluigi Donnarumma, leaving him out in the cold.
For Newcastle, the situation now feels like a market opportunity that has swung back in their favour.
Trafford is at a stage of his career where development hinges on regular Premier League exposure, something City cannot currently guarantee.
That creates a rare chance for Newcastle to act decisively and secure a goalkeeper moulded for modern, progressive football.
Advertisement
On Trafford, Pep Guardiola said (via the BBC), “He is so reliable. Fantastic keeper.”
Trafford’s distribution, composure under pressure, and ability to play a high defensive line fit seamlessly with the direction Newcastle want to evolve towards.
More importantly, the club needs succession planning due to uncertainty over Pope. Waiting any longer risks another rival stepping in.
If Newcastle are serious about building a squad capable of sustained European pushes, this is the summer to land their long-term No.1.
